Sal Stewart, Alec Burleson and the Mid-Round CI Breakouts

Back in February and March, I produced a series of articles comparing players at similar ADPs for each position. I broke down each set of hitters by four pillars: playing time and role, health and durability, skills and categorical contributions, and context of team offense. In re-reading my articles, the March 10, 2026 piece on middle-round corner infielders stood out because it covered a goldmine ADP cluster that featured two eventual fantasy difference-makers and two others who provided substantial fantasy profit. Let’s revisit that cluster of first basemen and third basemen, a journey that may be a joyful trip down Memory Lane for some, and a FOMO nightmare to others.

The ADP range of corner infielders analyzed was the Rounds 15-16 range of 17 NFBC Online Championship 12-team leagues in the second week of March. Here are those seven hitters:

Never in our wildest roto dreams would we have predicted that the top two run producers in the National League would come out of this cluster! Alec Burleson and Sal Stewart didn’t just earn profits, they were roto monsters. More on the this group in a bit, let’s first take a look at their ADP movement in March.

ADP Movement – Mid-Round Corner Infield Cluster
# Player Team P1 ADP P2 ADP Delta
1 Sal Stewart CIN 173 140 33
2 Royce Lewis MIN 175 209 -34
3 Alec Burleson STL 178 173 5
4 Spencer Torkelson DET 183 197 -14
5 Addison Barger TOR 184 194 -10
6 Jonathan Aranda TBR 190 199 -9
7 Kazuma Okamoto TOR 193 194 -1
P1 ADP: March 5 – March 9 (17 OC drafts)
P2 ADP: March 23 – March 26 (46 OC drafts)

Sal Stewart was a rocket ship, rising nearly three full rounds from early March to the final week of draft season. Drafters were miffed on how to adjust his draft value after the mid-February news about him losing 26 pounds in the offseason. Would he lose some of his power upside or would the assumption of improved fitness and athleticism help? By the time that MLB.com reported that Stewart was projected to bat fourth for the Reds on Opening Day (on March 23), Stewart’s draft helium was already on the rise. Concerns about any reduction in power was curtailed by the power (five homers) he displayed in exhibition games.

The Perennial Disappointment 

On the other end of the spectrum was the highly polarizing, oft-injured Royce Lewis. Perhaps we should have known that a maimed zebra doesn’t change its stripes. Lewis was scratched from a Grapefruit League game in late-February, but returned on March 3. The ensuing week was his minimum ADP period, but as he struggled through spring games (6-for-45, .133), his ADP dropped approximately three rounds. Over those final four days of OC drafts, Lewis earned a max pick as low as 281 overall.

Lewis hit home runs in the second and third games of the regular season, then predictably hit the IL with a left knee sprain on April 11.  He struggled over the next several weeks, was demoted to Triple-A on May 19, raked while there, and was recalled on June 10 for the remainder of the season. Lewis transferred that positive momentum into the Twins lineup and batted .279 with five homers — his highest average and home run total in any of the next four months.

Lewis set career-highs in games played (126), plate appearances (509), runs (51), runs batted in (57) and stolen bases (16), but his power metrics (89.8 EV, 10.7% BRL, 40.2% HH) were mediocre, his strikeout rate (25.5%) was a career-worst mark, and he slashed a meager .227/.287/.380 for the season. Lewis was rostered in most 12-team OCs for the majority of the season, but was rarely of roto assistance, outside of swiping four bags in Week 18. Any of that luster surrounding Lewis from that Ruthian run he had in first half of 2024 has mostly worn off. If he defies odds and pops off a massive profit in 2027, it will be as a 300+ ADP pick.

The other corner infielders in this range hovered within the same two-round ADP range for most of March.

The Injury Bust

Addison Barger’s season was over before it really ever began. In his first full season in 2025, he broke out, hitting 21 HR with 74 RBI with strong power metrics — 91.7 EV, 11.4% BRL, 50.9% HH. In the playoffs, he slashed .367/.441/.583 with 3 HR in 68 PA. The only valid argument against drafting Barger was that he was likely going to sit often against left-handed pitchers. Nevertheless, this was an ADP range where taking a power-heavy platoon bat wasn’t a big deal, since we could also optimize his platoon splits within the scoring periods.

Barger produced in spring training (.367/.429/.733), went 0-for-4 on Opening Day, and was on the bench against a lefty starter for the second game of the season. On April 5, he was removed from a game due to bilateral ankle discomfort, and it was all downhill from there. Manager John Schneider downplayed the injury, but two days later, Barger was placed on the injured list, with the expectation that he would only miss the minimum of 10 days. He was reinstated on May 9, went 0-for-5 in that game against the Angels, then was scratched the following game.

That day, it was reported that he would undergo an MRI on his right elbow. He started ramping up baseball activities in late-June, and was shut down again due to a stress reaction in his back. Not long after the All-Star break, he was transferred to the 60-day IL for his back and elbow injuries, and on July 24, it was announced that he would undergo season-ending surgery to repair the UCL in his right elbow. His status for next season is unknown.

Just a Guy

Kids these days overuse many terms, including mid and perhaps that’s what how best to describe 2020 top MLB draft pick, Spencer Torkelson. Us 80s kids might have called him bogus or a major drag. He hasn’t driven in more than 78 runs in any of the last two seasons, has never hit more than 31 home runs in a season, and has a horrendous .228 career batting average over 2,730 plate appearances. His roto stat line of .230-66-26-77-1 was reasonable for the price, but it was nothing to be excited about. Five of his 26 home runs last season were hit in Week 5 and he never hit more than two homers in any other week.

Torkelson was helpful in the final month of the season for those who held and started him (.292-12-6-14-1 in 91 PA). Over that period, he struck out at a rate of nearly 32 percent, which was essentially his full-season rate (31.7%). Typically a better overall hitter against southpaws in his first four seasons, Torkelson hit better against righties (119 wRC+) than lefties (105 wRC+) in 2026. Unfortunately, his isolated power (ISO) against lefties dipped considerably — from .270 the previous three seasons to just a .123 in 2026.

Digging into Tork’s underlying metrics this offseason isn’t going to spark a desire to push him up our draft rankings to take a chance on a HR+/BA- profile. Anything is possible, though. If we hear he went to Driveline, is launching missiles in spring training games and our buddy Paul Sporer vouches for him, perhaps we’ll see a bit of Tork helium.

Pleasant Profits

Jonathan Aranda definitely fit the mold of “sharp mid-round pick” and “reasonable first base punt.” Though Aranda wasn’t an outright draft target for me, he was one of the post-150 ADP first basemen I would have been fine with if I missed out early targets (Pete Alonso, Matt Olson, Bryce Harper), along with Willson Contreras, Alec Burleson and Jake Burger.

Aranda felt like a sharp pick for several reasons, but the biggest one was that he was projected for a middle-of-lineup, full-time role, had strong underlying metrics, and experienced a mini-breakout in 2025. Moreover, many of the sharper analysts and high-stakes players appeared to be on board with Aranda as a later-round value who could produce a substantial profit margin. In 2025 (422 PA), Aranda batted .316 (.291 xBA), with a .393 OBP, .489 SLG and solid power peripherals: a 12.8% barrel rate and a 54.1% hard-hit rate.

Aranda did not disappoint as a full-time player in 2026, slashing .274/.358/.434 with 73 R, 22 HR and 92 RBI, earning $14.9 in 12-team roto, which was 10th best among first basemen who started the season with that position’s eligibility. Technically, he was 12th if we include two undrafted studs who out-earned him, Liam Hicks and Jake Bauers. Aranda was a true Occam’s razor pick — he passed the eye test, his stats had analytical support, and he was projected for more playing time — the simplest move was to look the draft-value horse in the mouth and draft him.

Kazuma Okamoto was hailed as the higher floor/lower upside Munetaka Murakami. Okamoto would regularly crush 30-40 dingers per season in the NPB, so a mid-20s HR projection was reasonable, but not the 30+ Murakami projected for. Though Murakami typically struck out at a 10-12% higher rate than Okamoto and both were double-digit walk rate guys, aggregate batting average projections in FanGraphs models weren’t that far apart — around .219 for Murakami and .240 for Okamoto. Murakami finished the season with a .207 average and 35 homers in just 553 PA (127 games). Okamoto was the Blue Jays offensive MVP, producing a .233 average, with 81 runs, 33 homers, 92 runs batted in and three stolen bases. He earned $14.4 in 12-team roto, just a half dollar shy of Aranda as the duo tied for 21st in the Majors in RBI. Ironically, they tied with another hitter who earned first base eligibility like Murakami and Okamoto — Luis García Jr.

Roto Monsters

This is what I wrote about Sal Stewart in the team offense context section in that March 10 article:

The best offensive context among this group is that of the Reds. Great American Ball Park is an elite hitters’ park, ranking third in overall Park Factor (103) and second in HR Park Factor (123). Stewart currently projects to bat fifth behind Elly De La Cruz and Eugenio Suárez. It’s a righty-heavy lineup that Stewart can earn full-time at-bats in. It would not be shocking to see him smash his aggregate RBI projection of 66. Stewart had a strong success rate in stolen bases (84%, 27-of-32) and should have the green light so long as Elly and Suárez aren’t clogging up the base paths.

Stewart did, indeed, smash the aggregate RBI projection, leading the Majors for a big chunk of the season and finishing third (112), the first rookie to exceed 110 since Alonso in 2019. Stewart nearly doubled RBI projections, though models thoughtfully projected around 485 plate appearances in 120 games. Stewart started all 162, amassing 700 PA, one of 14 hitters with 700 or more.

His power metrics were around league average (90.5 EV, 11.9% BRL, 41.6% HH), but Stewart didn’t have massive home/road splits in favor of his home park. In fact, Stewart hit two fewer homers at Great American Ball Park (15) than on the road (17) in just 10 fewer plate appearances, and hit for a lower average there (.257 vs. .269). He rarely moved out of the heart of the Reds lineup, starting 52 games in the two-hole, 53 batting third, and 54 batting cleanup.

If there was one negative to note, it was his success rate on the basepaths. Through May 16, he stole 10 bases without being caught. From May 17 on, he attempted to steal only 13 more times, getting caught eight times. An 84% success rate in the minors from 2024-2025 (27-for-32) dipped down to 65% last season. We’re unlikely to see models project for more than the 15 he swiped last season.

All in all, Stewart ($27.7) finished 13th among hitters on the 12-team Player Rater, 18th overall, which was a massive profit for everyone who invested, including those who pushed him up their boards with aplomb.

Alec Burleson ($26) came in 19th among hitters (24th overall) on the Player Rater, providing fantasy managers with a solid second-round return. He lead the Majors in runs batted in (116), and set career highs in games played (160), plate appearances (670), runs (89), homers (26), slugging percentage (.473), barrel rate (11.3%) and hard-hit rate (50%). After batting .290 and .269 in the two previous seasons, Burleson followed up with a respectable .279, supported by an xBA of .289 and near-league-average BABIP of .310. He did not handle left-handed pitching well (.212 BA, .088 ISO, .242 wOBA, 51 wRC+), but dominated against righties (.311, .243, .402, 158) — an argument in favor of analysts predicting a statistical regression in 2027.

Regression will be on everyone’s roto evaluation card, but the question would then be: regression to what? If it’s a 15-20% overall decline in his 5×5 line, we’re still looking at a top 50 hitter at a reasonable price tag, assuming his early 2027 NFBC ADP in the 45-60 range doesn’t sharply rise. That’s in stark contrast to the value lost in Sal Stewart at his 2027 second-round ADP at an overall regression of 15-20%. Though arguments can be made that Stewart is more likely to remain around last year’s levels or even improve.

Here were my final value grades for this cluster back in early March:

Verdict (with value grades, A-F)

Alec Burleson (B) is the best all-around value and has the highest floor. He gets an extra boost to his value for his dual (1B-OF) eligibility.

Kazuma Okamoto (B) feels like a risky proposition considering he’s never played in the majors and will have much to adjust to. He’s the one guy in this tier I’m most confident will produce a profit at his price tag.

Sal Stewart (B-) is the most volatile of the bunch as a rookie with very little big league experience. He has arguably the most upside and offers additional value in the stolen base category.  He’s the hitter most likely to surge into the tier above.

Jonathan Aranda (B-) officially broke out last season and has an above-average floor, but we should be careful projecting a plus batting average and assuming that he will play against left-handed pitchers all season.

Spencer Torkelson (C+) has massive batting average downside, but makes up for it with strong power production (30 HR, 85 RBI) for a hitter in this range. If you’re a BA snob, draft other sources of power.

Royce Lewis (C+) is incredibly polarizing because of his massive prospect pedigree and some epic production stretches that balance out with legitimate concerns about his ability to stay on the field.

Addison Barger (C) exhibited plus power against righties in his breakout season. I’m lower on him than the market and haven’t been drafting him because I prefer other corner infielders in this range. His struggles against lefties likely won’t go away this season, and it’s more difficult to roster platoon bats in shallow redraft leagues.

Not that far off from results, with the only likely difference had I written this article 2-3 weeks later, moving Stewart up to a B grade. With 2027 drafts underway on NFBC and as we get closer to the heart of draft season, you can be certain that you’ll see an article from me about undervalued corner infielders who we should consider targeting. We may not have the same class or success rate of the 2026 mid-round group, nor a This Year’s Sal, but I’ll do my due diligence and lay it all out as cogently as possible.





Vlad writes for RotoGraphs and is the head of fantasy baseball content at FTN Fantasy. He is a Tout Wars Expert League champ, member of the CDM Fantasy Sports Hall of Fame and has been nominated for FSWA writing awards six times. Vlad has been playing fantasy baseball since 1995, winning 42 NFBC leagues since 2012 and ranking in the top percentile in NFBC’s Online Championship contest (33% win rate, 52% cash rate; 64 leagues). Much to the chagrin of his colleagues and most baseball aficionados, Vlad is a lifelong Dodgers fan who claims his first gut call at age 9 was Kirk Gibson’s 1988 World Series home run. You can follow him on X and BlueSky @RotoGut.

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Lanidrac
25 days ago

How was Burleson a breakout? He was almost as good last year, and he even arguably “broke out” the year before that in 2024.

While his WAR was much higher this year, that was mostly due to defensive improvements by playing 1B full time (and also improving his defense there) instead of spending much of his playing time playing poor defense in the corner outfield. Defense doesn’t matter for fantasy baseball, anyway.

So, for any drafters who are only now realizing just what an offensive stud Alec Burleson is, that’s on them for not paying proper prior attention to him.