4 Pitchers to Rebuy in 2027

Fall drafts are already underway over at the NFBC and I’ll be getting started on some myself in November. I’ve been hard at work making my initial lists and in the process found a handful of guys I’m willing to rebuy in 2027 despite less than stellar results this year. Three of the four were north of a 5.00 ERA while the other was at 4.57 which still isn’t helping in any format. That said, I think all of ’em have enough talent and/or a cheap enough price to run it back next year. The 4th is definitely more of the Hail Mary variety with niche fantasy viability, but the other three all have major breakout potential next season.
Emmet Sheehan | LAD – 4.57 ERA/1.18 WHIP/21% K-BB in 112 IP
The skills were there even if the results never quite followed, but there is a clear issue that needs fixing. The juxtaposition of his struggles in comparison to teammate Justin Wrobleski’s success was particularly frustrating for those who had Sheehan on their roster. Through their first 14 starts, Sheehan had a 5.32 ERA/1.30 WHIP combo despite a 26% K and 19% K-BB while Wrobleski boasted a sparkling 2.51 ERA/1.00 WHIP combo with his meager 15% K and 10% K-BB. It did show that as valuable as K% and K-BB% can be, they don’t always tell the whole story. BABIP and HR rates underscored their stark differences in results.
Sheehan had a modest .307 BABIP and truly awful 1.9 HR9 while Wrobleski excelled in both at .232 and 0.77, respectively. It seemed like Wrobleski was fortunate to maintain such a low BABIP with as much contact as he allowed and it regressed in the second half (.331 in final 54 IP), even as his bat-missing improved (28% K). The only real case that Sheehan’s BABIP was unlucky (20 pts north of league avg) is the fact that flyball pitchers generally run lower BABIPs as they are less susceptible (but not immune) to sneaky bleeders and bloops that groundballers suffer. The homers, however, were a problem that simply can’t be hand-waved as bad luck.
The same flyball lean that could alleviate some BABIP pain obviously plays into his home run problem and his 15% HR/FB rate was only three points above average making it tough to suggest he was suffering through bad fortune there. Even the 17% mark in his first 14 starts felt more like his own issue than anything luck-based. Checking the Savant HR tracker to see how many “Doubters” (HRs that only would’ve been out in 1-7 parks) he had further lays waste to any notion of bad luck. Of the 21 homers he allowed, only 2 fit the Doubter category (the 7 listed on that tracker are “expected homers” so he had 5 other batted balls that would’ve been homers in 1-7 parks).
Homers weren’t a new problem for Sheehan, either. He had a 1.6 HR9 and 13% HR/FB in his 60-inning debut back in 2023 and simple good luck seemed to be behind his 0.86 HR9 in 2025 as his HR/FB dipped to a very favorable 9% mark. So this is the hurdle Sheehan needs to overcome to become the stud the rest of his skillset suggests. It comes down to his fastball which has been responsible for 69% of his homers and a 6% HR rate on the 445 PA that ended on a fastball. I don’t know where that ranks among all fastballs (I’m unaware of a leaderboard that offers up HRs by pitch so if you know of one, please drop it in the comments), but it’s double the 3% league home run rate over his career so I can’t imagine it ranks very well.
He either needs to greatly improve his fastball command or alter it in some way, perhaps even switching to a sinker. I tend to find homer issues something that can be overcome, though, so while it is a significant wart for Sheehan, the core skills are too strong for me to ignore so I’ll happily rebuy even around pick-160.
Andrew Painter | PHI – 5.40 ERA/1.41 WHIP/12% K-BB in 127 IP
After a brutal 2+ months that led to a monthlong demotion, Painter returned with a slimmed down arsenal and started to deliver on the hype of a 5-time Top 100 prospect. It’s not like the 65 IP before being sent out was nearly enough to make any definitive judgments on him, but it was nice to see his season finish on a high note. In 62 IP down the stretch, he went from five to three pitches, shelving the sinker and curveball and shifting his off-speed pitch from 87-mph splitter to a 91-mph changeup.
The results were strong with a 3.68 ERA/1.16 WHIP/15% K-BB including at least 6 Ks in 8 of the 11 starts. His SwStr rate jumped 3 points to 13%, a mark only 14 qualified pitchers reached in 2026. There were still a few Duds, but that’s fine, he needn’t be perfect to be a worthy breakout candidate. In early Fall drafts, he’s got an ADP of 220. There a couple mid-100s outliers among the 12 drafts of data (148, 155), but he is mostly living in the 210-240 range. He could be a Winter riser with offseason helium pushing him more in the 175-190 range, a price point that currently features starters like Jackson Jobe, Walbert Ureña, and Kyle Harrison. Painter certainly wouldn’t be out of place there and I’d still be open to buying.
Noah Schultz | CHW – 5.57 ERA/1.33 WHIP/11% K-BB in 74 IP
It was a bumpy 74-inning debut for the lefty, but this is a classic hang with ‘em for a young prospect with gobs of talent. He couldn’t bring his Triple-A success to the majors (2.01 ERA/0.87 WHIP/19% K-BB in 45 IP) but we still saw glimpses of his upside amidst the struggles including three 60+ Game Scores (no, GS isn’t the most sophisticated stat but it’s a good first level check to identify good/bad starts).
He’s got a mid-90s heater (that touches 98-99), a couple swing-and-miss breakers, and a deep arsenal against both sides of the plate (4 pitches v. LH; 5 v. RH) that gives him options when his best pitches aren’t working on a given day. I do wish we’d have seen more whiffs (21% K, 9% SwStr) in the majors after double-digit SwStr rates all the way up the minor league chain, but I think it’s in there and as a post-400 pick, I’ll take a shot on the 23-year old taking a developmental step in his first full season in the majors.
Jack Perkins | ATH – 6.10 ERA/1.45 WHIP/17% K-BB in 121 IP
As someone who rostered Perkins multiple times throughout 2025, you might be surprised to learn that I’m willing to go back to the well with him and frankly, that’s fair. Perk was at best a road-only starter, which is a scary proposition for any streamer. Even his road work still amounted to just a 4.66 ERA/1.30 WHIP but I’m a sucker for the 26% K rate. In fact, he had a 26% mark at home, too, he just couldn’t overcome a devastating 2.4 HR9 in that bandbox of a park making it nearly impossible to start him there.
I’ve already made clear that I’m a big fan of K-BB while fully understanding its limitations in identifying quality pitchers. He’s like a scarier Sheehan with the strong K-BB being limited by far too many homers and the added factor of a terrifying home park. Thankfully, he’s priced like a streamer, going around pick-400 in Fall drafts. He’s the first one of this group that is a pure lottery ticket for me. I’m not going to pretend there isn’t massive risk with him especially as someone you should likely only use half the time.
Teammate Jacob Lopez could be considered sort of a buy-one-get-one free combo with Perkins. He’s going around pick-580 in Fall drafts which is damn near free (as he should be because he shares all the same risks as Perkins without the same skill upside, at least not last year). Lopez had a 28% K rate back in 2025 but dipped to just 20% last year and he was actually worse on the road (5.71 ERA/1.59 WHIP). I probably wouldn’t pair the duo despite my framing as a BOGO set but rather take either/or in some of my Draft Champions (50-round draft and hold) leagues that I will be starting up in November.


Howdy Paul, how are you finding adp for the too early drafts? Thanks!
Oh man I didn’t even know they weren’t loaded on NFBC yet. I subscribe to Bubba & Bloom Patreon and they have a board of ’em so I just went there first.
I’m big into Sheehan and Painter as value buys. I also expect Painter to rise throughout the winter–his strong postseason performance contributes to that expectation. And even with a robust rise, he’s a solid target.
Sheehan…I don’t have as strong of a read on price-wise. Likely a big delta between NFBC and classic redraft too. Role looks pretty iffy, especially if they nab Skubal. Then again, they might ship him out in that scenario (perhaps to unload all of Teoscar’s salary). I imagine he’ll have a huge range, even on NFBC.
I have less to say about Schultz and Perkins. They’re valid late dart throws who I’d rather stash than use. I’d like to see Grant Taylor and Schultz flip roles. Perkins has the repertoire of a starter, but more time in relief might help him to refine that pitch mix to achieve greater effect.
I’m hoping Sheehan gets shipped. The Dodgers seem uninterested in investing much in his development — hard to blame them for buying a rotation of elite arms — and he could be a lock-down MOR starter in a park that played to his fly-ball tendencies.
He’s fun to watch and I think he’s a better pitcher for losing some mustard on his FB. His command has been pretty good the last two seasons, and at just 25 there’s a lot of runway left. He should be somewhere that needs him, not where he’s a “nice to have.”
I was kinda hoping he’d be in the Skubal deal for my Tigers
Ditto.
common thread between all of these guys is they are well below average at inducing ground balls which leaves them very babip and HR% dependent. Sheehan posts a 8% HR/FB ratio and is amazing then this year posts a 15% HR/FB ratio and was terrible.
I’m not sure there is a direct one, so I made one using Baseball Savant data: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1RcORdM7u4ZVV3c9MOUc8fYcf3EEzbJfGTk1zwlzeuwI/edit?usp=sharing
Since I was there, I actually included all four major pitch groups from Statcast, and it is for 2022 through 2026.
As far as Sheehan, there are 338 pitchers that have thrown at least as many fastballs as Sheehan’s 1,991 in this time frame. His 6.07% HR/Fastball PA is second highest to Shota Imanaga, who has a whopping 6.91% HR/Fastball PA. His raw HR/Fastball of 1.36% is sixth highest, behind Imanaga, Josiah Gray, and three guys who played most of their games in Coors (Sugano, Gomber, and Blach). His fastball usage is below league average over this time, but maybe it should be even lower…
Yessss this fricken rips, thank you so much!
Just buy whoever the Rays go for lol
Can’t sugar coat any Rockies or Sacto pitcher… sorry, it is you don’t pass Go and collect $200… you get sent to jail. Why would anyone take a risk on pitchers that have half their games in a softball field? Sheehan? Okay gamble but his Hr Ball is terrible. Great team to outscore opponents, but also look at his 5th and 6th innings. No stamina. Schultz is a gamble that his sore left shoulder is a temporary thing.
Ya you’re not wrong on Sacto-Coors. I gotta get over my Perk fixation looool.
Buy talent, not location
Generally agree, but I do think Coors & Sacto are exceptions. Those home stadiums simply won’t be defeated
Love this; literally all of those pitchers were on my fantasy team last season lol